Skip to Content

Compost Vs. Manure: The Differences and What Plants Like More

Spread the Word!

Both manure and compost provide essential nutrients to the soil and can improve its structure.

However, there are some key differences between the two that you should know about before you use them on your plants.

Compost is made from decomposed organic matter such as fruit and veggie scraps, coffee grounds, and garden waste, whereas manure is the decomposing organic matter produced by livestock. Compost has a more diverse range of nutrients, while manure has a higher nitrogen and potassium content depending on its origin.

In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of each option as well as how to use them in your garden.

Compost Vs. Manure

Compost Vs Manure

Composting and manure provide varying levels of nutrients, so it’s important to know the pros and cons of each to choose wisely.

Compost is made from decomposed organic matter such as fruit and veggie scraps, tea bags, coffee grounds, and garden waste.

It improves soil structure through increased water and oxygen permeability, stabilizes pH levels, resists compaction, reduces erosion, and provides antibacterials due to microorganism digestion processes of organics.

Compost also provides a diverse range of nutrients that are readily available.

On the other hand, manure comes from livestock’s digestive systems and can include bedding.

Fresh manure contains high amounts of nitrogen, which can benefit grass due to its higher nitrogen content.

However, fresh manure can also contain disease-spreading organisms such as E.coli or tapeworms that could potentially infect humans.

Chicken or cow manure has varying levels of nutrients, with chicken being high in nitrogen while the cow is potassium-rich.

Therefore, it is important to understand these differences between compost and animal manure when considering what nutrient application best suits your gardening goals.

What is Manure?

You may have heard of adding compost to your gardens and soils, but did you know that manure can also be used as an amendment?

Manure is the decomposing organic matter produced by livestock.

Each has its own benefits and drawbacks, depending on what kind of soil amendment you need for your garden.

Types of Manure

There are various types of manure available to use in your garden, from chicken to sheep, each offering different levels of nutrients.

There are many different types of manure are available, including:

  • Cow,
  • Sheep,
  • chicken,
  • Goat
  • Horse manure

Horse manure is the most abundant type and can be used raw or aged. It’s high in nitrogen but low in other essential nutrients.

Animal dung, such as cow and sheep manure, has a higher nutrient content than horse manure but can contain parasites, so it should be avoided if possible.

Raw manure should never be used on food-producing plants as it may carry diseases that could contaminate the crop.

Chicken manure has one of the highest nitrogen levels available and is also rich in phosphorous and potassium, making it an ideal choice for flowering plants or vegetables that require more fertilizer.

What is Compost?

Composting is a great way to recycle organic waste and create nutrient-rich soil for your plants. Compost is made from decomposed organic matter, such as fruit and veggie scraps, tea bags, coffee grounds, and garden waste.

There are many types of compost materials available that can help you build the perfect compost pile for your backyard garden.

Types of Compost

Understanding the types of compost available can help you decide which is best for your garden needs.

Compost is an organic material that can be made from food waste, yard trimmings, and other household materials. It’s a nutrient-rich soil amendment that helps to improve soil structure and promote plant growth.

  • 1. Bagged store-bought compost
  • 2. Homemade compost
  • 3. Mushroom compost
  • 4. Green waste compost
  • 5. Worm castings (Vermicompost)
  • 6. Leaf mold
  • 7. Potting compost

Knowing the benefits of each will help you choose which type of soil amendment will work best for your garden needs.

What is the Difference Between Manure and Compost?

Knowing the differences between compost and manure can help you decide which is best for your garden.

The main difference between manure and compost is the origin of the organic material used to produce them; manure comes from animals, while compost comes from plants and other organic matter.

Compost and manure are both great options for organic waste, but they have unique benefits regarding soil structure and nutrient content.

Here are five key differences between compost and manure:

Higher water retention rateBetter suited for grass
More diverse range of nutrientsHigh nitrogen content
Any organic materials can be usedMostly from farm animals’ digestive systems
Safer to use on vegetable gardensDifferent types of animals produce different kinds of manures with various levels of nutrients which can burn plants.

Should I Use Compost Or Manure?

When it comes to fertilizing your garden, you may be wondering if you should use compost or manure.

Compost is best used on vegetables and flowers that need lots of nutrients, while manure is better for grass due to its higher nitrogen content.

Compost and pasteurized or hot-composted manure are both good choices for flowers.

Ultimately, your decision will depend on the type of plants you’re growing and the resources available to you.

Plants To Use Compost on

Compost is made up of decomposed organic matter like fruit and veggie scraps, tea bags, coffee grounds, and garden waste. It’s a great way to improve soil structure while retaining moisture.

Plants that can grow in compost include vegetables, carrots, tomatoes, and spring onions.

Although abundant nutrients can be found in the organic matter mix, growing your plants in compost mix alone would cut them off from access to the many benefits the soil offers.

Plants to Use Manure on

Manure can provide a balanced range of nutrients to garden soils, such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium. Plus, it provides microorganisms that help improve soil structure.

Manure is an excellent choice for grass because of its high nitrogen content. It’s also great for flowers due to its beneficial nutrient profile.

Hot-composted or pasteurized manure is safe for vegetables and herbs in your garden if applied at the right time in the growing season.

Make sure to check the nutrient percentages when using manure, so you know how much to apply without risking over-fertilizing your plants. 

Can You mix Compost and Manure?

You can create nutrient-rich, loamy soil for your plants by mixing compost and manure.

Mixing compost with manure is the best choice for soil health as it yields a rich, loamy organic substance that provides a more diverse range of nutrients.

It can also help keep weeds at bay, reduce erosion, and build up the microbial population in your soil. Both materials contain different levels of macro and micronutrients that will feed your plants over time.

It also creates a balanced nutrient profile, which is essential for plant growth and sustainability.

Here are some benefits of mixing compost and manure:

  • Improves soil structure through increased water and oxygen permeability
  • Stabilizes pH and helps to neutralize soils
  • Increases moisture retention in soils
  • Adds beneficial microorganisms and insects to the soil

Composting with manure is an excellent way to provide essential nutrients while improving the health of your garden.

Manure helps add nitrogen to the soil, while compost provides some natural antibacterial protection against disease.

How To Use Compost?

Discover how compost can help your garden thrive by adding nutrient-rich, loamy soil to your plants.

Composting is an easy and sustainable way to create this soil supplement.

All you need is some organic material such as fruit or vegetable scraps, tea bags, coffee grounds, and garden waste that are broken down through microbial processes into a crumbly black substance.

Compost also helps improve the structure of the soil by increasing water and oxygen permeability while also reducing compaction and erosion.

It can also help neutralize pH levels in soils as well as stabilize them for better nutrient uptake by plants.

Additionally, compost has antibacterial properties due to processing through microorganisms’ digestive systems which helps prevent disease from spreading in the garden.

Lastly, composting with manure yields a balanced nutrient profile for the soil which is ideal for plant growth and sustainability.

So take advantage of all these benefits by taking time out of your day to start composting!

How To Use Manure

Manure is an organic material that can provide your plants with essential nutrients, just like compost – but it comes from livestock’s digestive systems instead.

It contains a lot of organic matter that is high in nitrogen due to the gut-processing activity of large animals.

Manure also helps increase soil’s moisture retention and improves drainage.

Here are three reasons why manure can be beneficial for your garden:

  1. Manure increases the organic content in soil, which helps to boost fertility and improve water retention.
  2. It provides a wide range of nutrients for your soil, including nitrogen, potassium, phosphorous and more.
  3. Manure has antibacterial properties and contains microorganisms that help break down organics in the soil.

Manure can be an effective way to nourish your plants while promoting healthy soils in the long run.

It is important to make sure you use pasteurized or hot-composted manure only as fresh manure can contain disease-spreading organisms and weed seeds, which may harm plants or people if not handled properly.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is pasteurized or hot-composted manure safe to use?

Yes, pasteurized or hot-composted manure is safe for soil amendment.

Hot composting helps to break down the manure into an organic material that is more easily absorbed by the soil, eliminating the potential for disease transmission and reducing the levels of nitrogen present.

This method also helps to reduce weed seeds and any lingering pesticide or herbicide residue.

How long does it take for compost or manure to decompose?

Composting and using manure in your soil are both great options for providing nutrients to your plants.

However, it is important to understand that the time it takes for compost or manure to decompose varies greatly depending on the environment they are placed in.

Compost typically takes anywhere from one month up to two years, while manure can take a few weeks up to several months.

The best way to ensure your compost or manure is ready for use is by monitoring its color and texture – if it’s dark and crumbly, then you know it’s ready!

Is compost or manure better for vegetable gardens?

Manure is also decomposed organic matter, but it comes from livestock’s digestive systems and can include bedding.

Different types of manure have varying levels of nutrients – chicken manure is high in nitrogen, while sheep manure is potassium-rich.

Compost is a safer choice for vegetable gardens due to its lower nutrient profile, while manure can kick-start hot-composting systems due to its higher nitrogen content.

Knowing the pros and cons of both composting with manure or just composting will help you choose which option best fits your gardening goals!

The Takeaway

You’ve now learned the difference between compost and manure, their pros and cons, and how to decide which is best for your garden.

Compost is a great choice if you’re looking for slow-release nutrients that won’t burn your plants.

Manure is ideal if you need a quick nutrient boost with higher nitrogen content. You can also use both together if desired.

Whatever you choose, adding organic material like compost or manure to your soil will help improve its structure and make it more fertile for growing healthy plants.

So go ahead, give it a try!

Spread the Word!

Free Plant Care & Gardening Guides