Choosing the Best Water Pump for Aquaponics


Share this article

Aquaponic systems works by providing plants with nutrients derived from fish waste in a closed loop circulating system. Fishes, plants and bacteria works cooperately to create an ecosystem in which they can all thrive.

The best water pump for aquaponics and hydroponics is chosen based on the flow rate (GPH), head height, power consumption and pump placement. These factors determines how well the pump performs while circulating water throughout the system.

The water pump is plays a critical role in how well an aquaponic system does which is why it is important in choosing the right pump.

There are characteristics of a pump which determines how well it works and by having a basic knowledge of these, you can make an expert decision on the right water pump for your system. So read on! Lets get the right pump for your aquaponics or hydroponics system.

Build a successful system with these affordable equipment from amazon, that I’ve tried & tested on my setup.

Click on the links to see them

What’s the Purpose of a Water Pump in an Aquaponics system?

Circulating the water in aquaponics and hydroponics is extremely important. The pumps carries the water to the plants, from the fish or nutrient tanks, where they use the nutrients. The water then flows back to the tank where the water is again, enriched and the cycle continues.

The function of a pump is like the human heart. The person breaths in oxygen, the lung absorbs it into the blood stream, the oxygenated blood then goes to the heart where it is pumped to the rest of the body. Sadly, when the heart stops the persons dies. It’s the harsh reality.

It’s the same with aquaponics systems. Although its not a sudden death when the pump stops, which we will discuss further later on the article, the system will surely stop functioning if there is no intervention.

Plants in an Aquaponic system depend on getting water enriched with nutrients. The nutrient enriched water is used by the plants. These nutrients if allowed to build can form a harmful environment for the fishes and this is a vital part of the cycle.

NFT aquaponic system

After the nutrients are removed from the water. Its flows to a sump which houses the pump. The pump now boosts the pressure of the water and sends it to the fish tank.

The water then flows to the fish tanks where it removes the waste produced by the fishes. The rate at which the waste is removed from the tank is determined by the flow of the water from the pump.

The waste is then moved to the mechanical filter where the change in flow rate “knocks out” the heavier matter which settles at the bottom of the filter. The waste can be removed by simple opening a dump valve installed at the bottom of the mechanical filter where the wastes settles.

Aquaponics biofilter

The water with little waste then flows to the biofilter. The biofilter houses the majority of the bacteria in the system because it creates the right environment for them to live.


See a detailed article on How a Biofilter works here.


In the biofilter, the ammonia from the fish waste is converted firstly to nitrites and then to nitrates in a two step process called nitrification.

The Nitrates in the water or nutrient enriched water then flows to the plants, where it is then used for plant growth.

The cycle then repeats itself

How Flow Rate affects the Efficiency of the Pump?

Flow rate is the rate at which the pump pushes out and circulates water throughout the system.

Aquaponics and Hydroponics systems are driven by the flow of water through the system. The flow of this water is measured in gallons per hour or GPH. This is the units you will see when searching for pumps and also the part of the determining factor in choosing the right pump for your system.

A general rule of thumb is that the pump should be able to recirculate all the water in the system within two hours. Meaning, that if you have a 250 gallons IBC tank, the pump should have a flow rate of at least 125 GPH.

What can Affect Pump Flow Rate?

Flow rate of a pump can be affected by two factors

  1. Head height – Height at which the pump needs to carry the water
  2. Restriction in the pump’s discharge piping

Head Height –
The head Height is the distance between the surface of the water where the pump is being housed to the highest point at which the water is piped before it reaches its destination.

Rule of thumb – Lesser the Head Height, Greater the flow rate

This is because of gravity. Think about water in a vertical tube resting on a scale. The more water you fill in the tube the higher the water height gets in the tube and the more the water column weighs. As a result, it becomes harder push the water out from the tube, the higher the water column gets.

Now, applying this to the pump, it would be harder to pump the water out and therefore less water would reach the outlet of the pipe the higher the water column gets.

Restriction
Restrictions can cause the pump to become inefficient and not produce the desired flow rate just like head height even if the the head height is small. Restrictions can be in the form of piping size. If the outlet pipe from the pump is small it can restrict water flow just like having a partially closed valve connected to the pipe.

It is recommended to connect the same size of water pipes as the fittings which the pump comes with. This would prevent restrictions and the pump would give the flow rate it was intended to produce.

Other factors such as a blocked suction inlet can also cause restrictions in the flow, which is why the sump or container in which the pump is being housed should be kept clean of debris.

NFT rails

Flow Rate for Different Plant Systems

Different types of system would require different flow rates to the plants. The recommened flow rate should be applied to the fish tank and the filters to ensure that the waste is not building up and fouling the fish tank.

There is a modified system I have found that works well in keeping the flow rate in the fish tanks while varying the flow to the plants as desired. For me this system worked pretty well and produced a lot of crops rather than allowing the full flow rate of water to just circulate the entire system.

This system allows you to vary the nutrient water going to the plants depending on what type or size of system you may have and gives greater versatility to your farming needs.

It is difficult to really put a value to the rate at which you supply water to the plants themselves. For example.

A NFT (Nutrient Film Technique) system the flow rate should be much less than a DWC (Deep Water Culture System), since the rails are slanted slightly to that the water just trickles over the plant roots.

For a DWC and grow beds the flow rate can be lesser or equal to the output from the pump and will not affect plant growth.

Fish tank

Flow Rate for Fish Tanks

A faster flow rate would allow for more of the waste produced by the fishes to be removed out from the tank and into the mechanical filter. This results in a clean and clear fish tank and produces happy fishes.

On the other hand, a slow flow rate would not not be able to remove the waste in the fis tank fast enough. As a result, the tank would become dirty fast. The waste would build up in the fish tank itself resulting in more harmful ammonia being built up in the system causing death of both fishes and plants.

Fast flow rate = Less waste build up
Slow Flow Rate = More Waste build up.

For this reason the flow rate and removal of the heavier matter in the system in the mechanical filter is very important.

Power Consumption of Aquaponic Pumps

Power consumption plays a big role in aquaponics and hydroponics setups. If the system is solar powered it would even play a bigger part on how you choose the pump for the system.

You would want the power usage to be as low as possible for obvious reasons. The cost of production would drive the feasibility of the entire unit and therefore choosing the right pump for the application is important.

Different brands would feature different power consumption. I have created a table with the top brand of pump from amazon for comparison

Pump ModelPower ConsumptionFlow Rate (GPH)Average Cost
Hydrofarm25 watts400$25
EcoPlus 72831020 watts396$28
Simple Deluxe54 watts400$22
Uniclife25 watts400$15
CWKJ Pump25 watts400$17
VIVOSUN15 watts400$19
Ponics Pumps 25 watts400$33
PULACO25 watts400$18
Pump Comparison Chart

Placing Aquaponic Pumps Inline or Submersible?

Water pumps can be placed in both inline and submersible configuration. Both of these lineups produce the same desired effect for some time.

After some time in service the in-line configuration can may lead to build up of sediment on the suction piping.

Additionally, when the pump is on the outside of the sump, the suction has to be connected the sump with a bulk head or a uniseal. These connections tend to leak over the course of time.

The suction pipe also has its own limitations as the size can affect the performance of the pump.

On the other hand, placing the pump inside the sump in a submersible configuration has more benefits than placing it inline.

Their is no additional piping to cause the problems associated with connecting it from the outside.

Our recommendation is placing the pump submerged inside the sump without the filter padding on the suction. This is because, the filter pad tends to get fouled quickly and reduce the efficiency of the pump.

The Best Aquaponics Water Pump

Hydrofarm Active Aqua is the best pump for an aquaponic system because it was tried and tested by us. We bought a 550GPH pump for a 200 gallon fish tank. The pump is running for 3 years without little stopping and maintenance.

The pump features –

  • Powerful mag drive construction
  • Indoor and outdoor use
  • Oil free and environmentally safe
  • BPA free safe for aquaponic use
  • 6′ power cord
  • UL-listed

Note: Although the product recommends this pump for a 55 gallon system. From our experience we found that the flow will be too much for such a small system.

What can cause an Aquaponic Water Pump to Stop?

There are two main reasons which may cause a aquaponic water pump to stop pumping.

  1. Blockage in the piping
  2. Power outage

Blockage in the piping can cause the pump to stop pumping especially in an aquaponic system. Pieces of plant roots and leave as are the main culprits.

This can usually be prevented by conducting preventive maintenance. You don’t have to continuously keep watching the pump but a weekly peek into the sump usually works and helps prevent any buildup in the suction piping.

Power Outages –

Power outages obviously would stop the pump. But it’s always a best practice to keep the pump running even if there is a power outage.

Having a backup batteries with an automatic switching system can prevent downtime and keep the system running.

What happens if the Aquaponic Water Pump Stops?

Let’s assume you have a CHOP system, the most efficient and widely used system.

If the water pump stops the sump would tend to overflow since it’s the lowest point in the system.

The rest of the system would retain its level relative to the position of the outlet pipes installed on the individual components.

We have written an entire article showing how to maintain levels in an aquaponic system, especially when the water pump stops. See article here!

Should you Repair a Water Pump or Buy another?

We would recommend repairing the water pump since the only thing that really goes bad is the impeller shaft.

Over the course of time it either wears out or breaks. It’s a simple solid ceramic tube inserted inside the impeller which holds it in place.

Having one of these parts on hand can save a lot time.
Additionally, because they are relatively cheap you can also have another on standby in the event one fails.

Why can Aquaponics Pumps be Submerged in Water without Failure?

Water pumps can be submersered in water because the motor is insulated.

Submersible Induction motors can operate under water because the electrical circuits are totally insulated from harsh elements such as water.

The heat produced by the motor is dissipated into the water which in turn cools the motor.

JayLea

JayLea has a passion for plants and has been gardening since 2015. He has valuable knowledge about gardening and houseplant care and can answer everyday practical questions that every plant owner has.

Posts to pique your interest